Tuesday, December 31, 2019

2019 in Books


Nonfiction

Philosophical Papers Vol. 1+2 by Richard Rorty

I found some of these works to be excellent, but most to be beyond my scope. As such his writings on politics were of greater interest than some of his other commentaries – but even those weren’t without merit. A previous familiarity with Heidegger, Foucault, and Wittgenstein was why I was interested in the volumes, but my lack of knowledge of Davidson, Quine, Kuehn, and Derrida left me cold for large swaths.

A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking

The 2017 edition published the year before Hawking’s death, updated from the mid-90s edition, provides a wonderful, concise, clear explanation of cosmological physics up to an including the LIGO detection of gravitational waves. An excellent primer on where physics stands today.

What is Civilization? by David Wengrow

An odd little work – the main section shows, through archaeology, how closely related Mesopotamia and Egypt really were. It is bookended by a premise and a very short second sections that tries, vaguely, to connect the ideas as a refutation to Huntington’s “clash of civilizations”.

Qur’an translated by Abdullah Yusuf Ali

After reading the Bible and the foundational texts of Hinduism and Buddhism, the lack of the Qur’an was beginning to be a bit conspicuous. An interesting text, both in format and, to an extent, content; benefited by Ali’s copious commentaries and explanations.

The Cheese and the Worms by Carlo Ginzburg

A history which I’d long been familiar with, but had not read for myself. The peasant miller Menocchio’s ideas and worldview are truly fascinating in an era (late 1500s) when such thoughts were apparently uncommon – his inquisitors are astounded. But as Ginzburg deftly teases out, their origins in oral peasant culture and now-obscure works of the time were there all along, bubbling beneath the Church’s imposed dichotomous culture of orthodox and heretic.

In Pursuit of the Unknown by Ian Stewart

In this 2012 work Stewart explains 17 equations that changed the world. He ramps up quickly – chapter three is calculus – and sometimes covers concepts too hastily for a math dummy like me. Indeed, as he goes on, he expects ever greater familiarity, and doesn’t bother to explain much at all. It can be a little frustrating, but not too significantly – really an extra ten pages probably would’ve solved the problem.

Because Internet by Gretchen McCullough

The basic premise is simple: the internet has changed language. There are a lot of interesting examples and concepts put in, and it’s well-researched. A long-ish chapter on memes was interesting – but felt a little out of place. All in all, a good read if you look at it sooner rather than later, and it becomes a historical snapshot.

Stop Me if You’ve Heard This: A History and Philosophy of Jokes by Jim Holt

An interesting little read – essentially an essay – on how jokebooks came about, and some theories on why we laugh. Not a bad use of time, but will almost certainly leave one wanting more. Notably, I thought while reading, it seems unlikely that Asia produced no humor throughout history…

East is a Big Bird by Thomas Gladwin

For those not already familiar with Micronesian sailing techniques… The first couple of chapters are standard, interesting, anthropology of life on Puluwat – an island in Micronesia. The next two, making up the bulk of the text, are a relatively exhaustive account of canoes and sailing methods – admittedly impressive dead-reckoning done by the stars. The final chapter, however, was a real curveball: comparing abstract and concrete systems of thinking, linking them to educational heuristics, and seeing how all of this navigating inverts middle class American stereotypes of the public education system and intelligence.

Fiction

The Saga of Gunnlaug Serpent-Tongue

A short saga from my on-going quest to read all 80 of the (Penguin) Little Black Classics (LBCs). Honestly, one of the most interesting sagas besides the Burnt Njal – which this work references.

Come close by Sappho

Yet another Penguin LBC, this time a collection of Sappho’s poetry – which I was previously unfamiliar with. Pleasant little verses.

Woman much missed by Thomas Hardy

An LBC that contains a complete poetry collection: Poems of 1912-1913 by Hardy. A collection of touching verses on the subject of his wife, recently passed.

The Power and the Glory by Graham Greene

My first Greene novel. An interesting account of Catholicism, well-told and very well-paced.

Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert

I previously had only read “A Simple Heart” which was good, but hadn’t shown me what to expect from this excellent work of poetic realism. One of the best 19th century novels I’ve encountered.

Three Novels: Malloy, Malone Dies, The Unnamable by Samuel Beckett

Three narrative monologues which become increasingly combative towards the reader. Admittedly, by the time you get to the third section, you’re in a realm of fiction you’ve likely never encountered before – and perhaps never again will. Is that worth a struggle that makes Joyce seem fairly easy, and a nihilistic lack of crescendo and awe? Personally, no.

Scoop by Evelyn Waugh

I’ve been wondering what to think about this work. If Dave Chapelle hadn’t created the black, blind, white supremacist sketch, would it still be funny? Or if Spike Lee hadn’t directed BlackkKlansman? Or Richard Pryor written much of Blazing Saddles? Waugh is (very) white – so the humor of an otherwise well-written comic novel can be troubling when he deals with race. Key example that I wrestled with: There’s a civil war in an African nation, between communists on one side and fascists on the other – who insist they are pure Aryans, “we’re just swarthy”. If Chris Rock writes it, it’s hilarious. But I truly don’t know if it’s okay when Waugh does it, and I’m sort of leaning towards, no.

Returning Home: Tao-Chi's Album of Landscapes and Flowers by Shi Tao (Tao-Chi)

A very short album of reflective, somewhat melancholic poems, coupled with paintings by the author.

The Alexandria Quartet by Lawrence Durrell

This tetralogy is okay, but not great. This first volume, ‘Justine’, tells of a passionate love-affair, an affair which is cast into significant doubt by the second volume, ‘Balthazar’. ‘Justine’ has an interesting and novel literary device worth mentioning – the protagonist comes across a novel already written about the woman he desires, and compares his affair with her to the other author’s. ‘Balthazar’ tells of the same time period, but from a friend’s perspective, who had better information than our original narrator. The third volume shifts entirely, and was probably my favorite. ‘Mountolive’ abandons the simple love story and adds yet another layer of complexity to the time period, this time with a new, omniscient, narrator. It was actually a pity in the final installment, ‘Clea’ to have to return to the original narrator – and distinct from the other novels, move forward in time. Indeed, ‘Clea’ seemed to me the weakest of the set.

The Conservationist by Nadine Gordimer

Banned in South Africa for its anti-Apartheid themes, Gordimer places us in the mind of a conservative, bigoted, embodiment of white male privilege. The journey is not pleasant, but then, of course, it’s not supposed to be. The quality of writing, though, makes her Nobel Prize award understandable.

“Sully Prudhomme” from The Library of the World’s Best Literature by Sully Prudhomme

Prudhomme doesn’t have any definitive English translations of his collections on the market – not even old pieces you can try to dig up from his time. His poems can be found in the authorized Nobel Library, but also in this work, from 1917 (found on Bartleby, online), or amateur translation scattered online. The poems in this collection are sentimental, romantic, and fairly forgettable. Solely of interest to Nobel Laureate collectors.

Jean Christophe by Romain Rolland

This massive novel might have been a world classic – it blends together the naturalistic style and the psychological style which were the dominant forms of the late 19th century. Such a synthesis would have been noteworthy, except, that the work was finished in 1912, and such a combination was quickly relegated to a minor footnote in literary development, as Modernism exploded upon the scene. Further, the work is weighed down by the difficulties of those years – a primitive 1800s nationalism, antisemitism, long-winded passages about “the will”, etc. For two years of dedicated study I went through this story, and can’t really recommend it. It has rightly been forgotten in an apt and ironical fashion: Jean Christophe is, as happens, the story of a composer whose music, initially praised, ends up being surpassed and forgotten.

The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman by Laurence Sterne

There are a few novelties in this work. But the characters I found very disagreeable, and the premise extraordinarily dull. If you liked Swift’s “Tale of a Tub” and “Gargantua and Pantagruel” (all of it), then you’d likely enjoy this work.

Childhood’s End by Arthur C. Clarke

This was my first experience with Clarke, and, excepting some almost bizarre holdovers from the 1950s, the work was very good. It was an enjoyable premise, well-executed. A nice piece of sci-fi to cleanse the palette, but also to generate significant rumination.

Tobacco Road by Erskine Caldwell

Probably the bleakest, most broken set of characters to inhabit the American canon. A short, brutal, tale of wretches who go so far into degradation as to pass by tragedy.

R.U.R. by Karel Capek

An interesting little sci fi play, certainly worth an hour of most readers' time. Beyond just the origin of the term ‘robot’, the work serves as an interesting cautionary tale of capitalism.

Midnight’s Children by Salman Rushdie

Some years ago I read ‘Haroun and the Sea of Stories’ which I found pleasant but forgettable. Not so this work, which is, I think rightfully, a masterful blending of modernism and magical realism, and quite possibly an essential literary text of the 20th century.

Hunger by Knut Hamsun

A critical Modernist text, from 1890, the work relays the thoughts of a Raskolnikov-type, but one whom you can actually relate to and enjoy his thoughts – as he faces the rack and ruin of starvation.

August: Osage County by Tracy Letts

A sort of ‘Long Days Journey’ meets ‘Who’s Afraid’, set in Oklahoma in 2007. Darkly comic, ultimately, of course, tragic, and not a bad option for something to read.

Lais of Marie de France

Intriguing little stories of courtly love, composed in the mid-1100s. A thoroughly pleasant collection, whose main story, Eliduc, I’d been familiarized with in high school.

Dead Souls by Nikolai Gogol

I am fond of Gogol’s two short stories, “The Overcoat” and especially “The Nose”. The first volume is a very good work. The fragments of the second, unpolished, incomplete, and adding little of value, I think can and should be avoided – to only consider the work by the first, completed segment.

Youth and Typhoon by Joseph Conrad

Two unremarkable short novellas about life at sea that came with my copy of Heart of Darkness, but which I'd never gotten around to reading. One or two passages of good language, offset by more than typically racist depictions (especially Typhoon).

A Room with a View by E.M. Forster

An enjoyable little novel of young bourgeois romance told with comic irony, when such a tone had not yet staled. Not as powerful as ‘A Passage to India’ which I read a few years ago, but certainly not off-putting, leaving me open to more Forster in the future.

I Hate and I Love by Catullus

Returning to the Penguin Little Black Classics I finally encountered the verse of Catullus, and his continual love / scorn for Lesbia. A fine small collection of poems.

A Death in the Family by James Agee

Parts are incredibly poetic, and moving, but the motifs are now so commonplace that I found the overall work difficult to stay interested in.

Goblin Market by Christina Rossetti

Another Penguin LBC, again of a poet I did not previously know. Rossetti’s poems are mostly forgettable, but there are a few choice selections.

Speaking of Siva

An LBC of four Indian poets: Basavanna, Akka Mahadevi, and Allama Prabhu from the 1100s, as well as an earlier author, Devara Dasimayya. All the poems are ontological and theological, regarding Shiva.

The Night is Darkening Round Me by Emily Bronte

A final LBC for the year, a selection of poems comprised melancholic eternities. If you’re into that sort of thing. Personally, it continued to confirm my distaste for Bronte.

Graphic Novels

Superman: Red Son by Mark Millar et al.

What if Superman landed in Ukraine instead of Kansas? While not as sophisticated as Gaiman’s ‘Miracleman: The Golden Years’, ‘Red Son’ is still very entertaining. Glad I finally read it.

Saga vol. 9 by Brian K. Vaughan and Fiona Staples

At this point the writing is still good, the character development is still good, but the plot is beginning to feel a bit formulaic and repetitive.

Top 5

Midnight’s Children
A Brief History of Time (2017 edition)
Madame Bovary
Childhood’s End
The Cheese and the Worms

Honorable Mentions

Dead Souls
Hunger
In Pursuit of the Unknown
August: Osage County
The Power and the Glory

Monday, December 23, 2019

A Decade of Music

I didn't much care for the music of this decade.

There was good, interesting stuff out there, but you had to dig for it. I think it was Rolling Stone who said that pop music was more ambitious than ever these past ten years: and that's true. But it was not any more innovative, and that's troubling. What made it ambitious was mingling with a few other existing forms, but the synthesis never created something boldly new.

The best example of this I can think of is Rihanna's album "Anti". Like many of the highly-praised pop albums, there's some interesting diversity on there. But the tracks that got all the attention, and radio-play, were the inane ones, like "Work". The lyrics are awful, as is the music. Of these offerings Beyonce's "Lemonade" was probably the best, and, consequently showed up near the top of many of the End of the Decade lists. From the list of albums I passed on, it may be one of the highest.

Still, my own list will have some of those mainstream offerings, of course. I mean, "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" was incredible. Beyond the pop offerings, though, I went deeper in my search. Which musicians won MacArthur awards? Pulitzer prizes? The Pazz and Jop polls? Mercury prize?

Instead of ranking, I'm just going to drop a bunch of albums here that I actually liked, and then a whole bunch that I didn't. The hope then, is that you can see this final list is based off of careful consideration, and depth of research.

Albums of the Past Decade I Liked

21, Adele - This has held up well, and will be seen as the 'Tapestry' of our era.
Art Angels, Grimes - If I am going to listen to pop, I want it to be trippy, dream-pop.
Channel Orange, Frank Ocean - A nice concept album that holds up lyrically and sonically.
Damn, Kendrick Lamar - "Pimp" may be the more important album, but for now "Damn" is the magnum opus, with all the benefits that implies.
The Electric Lady, Janelle Monae - As usually the case, the interludes add nothing, but the rest of the work is so strong it's okay.
Floral Shoppe, Macintosh Plus - One of the few interesting little innovations of the decade was this vaporwave classic. But it was more curiosity than movement.
Freedom Highway, Rhiannon Giddens - Very good folk/Americana offering in an otherwise blah decade for that genre.
Golden Hour, Kacey Musgraves - Rightfully heralded, the first interesting album to come out of country music in a long while.
Hadestown, Anais Mitchell - I loved this concept album, with guest appearances from people like Bon Iver and Ani Difranco. Not to be confused  with the Broadway album, which I've not heard.
Hamilton, Lin-Manuel Miranda - Deserves all the love it got.
Heaven and Earth, Kamasi Washington - One of the more interesting jazz albums of recent years.
How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful, Florence + The Machine - A great tribute to the singer-songwriters of an earlier era: Ronstadt et al.
Ism, Steelism - A fun, relaxing, album by an underappreciated duo.
...Like Clockwork, Queens of the Stone Age - A solid blast of unpretentious California rock.
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, Kanye West - An indisputable masterpiece.
Radio Music Society, Esperanza Spalding - A nice jazz crossover; all in all a strong LP.
The Suburbs, Arcade Fire - This increasingly feels like the last great hurrah of the preceding decade.
Universal Beings, Makaya McCraven - Another of the interesting jazz albums of the decade.
The Untouchables, Casey Hurt - I saw this show in San Francisco and liked the music, so I got the cast album. It is the most idiosyncratic of all the choices.

And now, the research:

Albums of the Past Decade I Didn't Like

1989, Taylor Swift
American Dream, LCD Soundsystem
Anti, Rihanna
The Archandroid, Janelle Monae
Be the Cowboy, Mitski
Black Messiah, D'Angleo and the Vanguard
Blackstar, David Bowie
Blond, Frank Ocean
Blunderbuss, Jack White
Body Talk, Robyn
Bon Iver, Bon Iver
Born to Die, Lana Del Rey
Coloring Book, Chance the Rapper
Ctrl, SZA
Dirty Computer, Janelle Monae
El Camino, The Black Keys
Ghosteen, Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
I Like It When You Sleep..., The 1975
Idler Wheel, Fiona Apple
Invasion of Privacy, Cardi B
It's Album Time, Todd Terje
Lemonade, Beyonce
Let England Shake, PJ Harvey
Life of Pablo, Kanye West
LP1, FKA Twigs
El Mal Querer, Rosalia
Masseducation, St. Vincent
Matangi, M.I.A.
Melodrama, Lorde
Modern Vampires of the City, Vampire Weekend
A Moon Shaped Pool, Radiohead
Morning Phase, Beck
My Woman, Angel Olson
Norman Fucking Rockwell!, Lana Del Rey
Puberty 2, Mitski
Pure Heroine, Lorde
Random Access Memories, Daft Punk
Red, Taylor Swift
Run the Jewels 2, Run the Jewels
A Seat at the Table, Solange
Settle, Disclosure
Sound & Color, Alabama Shakes
St. Vincent, St. Vincent
Take Care, Drake
Tell Me I'm Pretty, Cage the Elephant
Teen Dream, Beach House
Thank U Next, Ariana Grande
This Is Happening, LCD Soundsystem
To Pimp a Butterfly, Kendrick Lamar
Wasting Light, Foo Fighters
When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?, Billie Eilish
Whokill, The Tune-Yards
Yeezus, Kanye West

There were more, that I'm forgetting, but that says more about the albums than their being on this list. Some of these were fine, just not anything special, some were very nearly good (Solange, Nick Cave, and Eilish got really close), and some were just bad.