I’ve been looking over
the National Recording Registry, lately. Many of the recordings you can’t get
access to, due to their scarcity, etc. So, to be more honest, I’ve been looking
over their selection of LPs.
Most of the time they
get it right, but I do have some quarrels with the list. I’ve divvied all of
their LPs into ones I agree with, disagree (and why), and haven’t heard. Some
LPs are difficult to find, too…
I have not included
classical LPs, as I’m not qualified to judge one rendition over another, with a
couple of slight-ish exceptions. Nor did I include spoken word LPs, except
comedy albums. Sorry to Dylan Thomas’ ‘A Child’s Christmas in Wales’. Likewise
I had to exclude anthologies, with all due apologies to Harry Smith. It is organized by year of induction.
Agree
2002
Dance Mania – Tito
Puente, 1958. Great album, deserved pick.
Kind of Blue – Miles
Davis, 1959. Essential.
The Freewheelin’ Bob
Dylan – Bob Dylan, 1963. Essential.
2003
Carnegie Hall Jazz
Concert – Benny Goodman, 1938. Essential.
Brilliant Corners –
Thelonious Monk, 1956. Great album, I understand the pick.
Mingus Ah Um – Charlie
Mingus, 1959. Essential. I’d also hear the argument for ‘The Black Saint and
the Sinner Lady’.
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely
Hearts Club Band – The Beatles, 1967. Essential.
At Folsom Prison –
Johnny Cash, 1968. Essential.
What’s Going On – Marvin
Gaye, 1971. Essential.
Tapestry – Carole King,
1971. Essential.
Born to Run – Bruce
Springsteen, 1971. Essential.
2004
Songs By Tom Lehrer –
Tom Lehrer, 1953. Great album. Still funny all these years later.
Drums of Passion –
Michael Babatunde Olatunji, 1960. Essential.
Live at the Apollo –
James Brown, 1963. Essential.
Pet Sounds – The Beach
Boys, 1966. Essential.
At Fillmore East –
Allman Brothers, 1971. Essential.
Nevermind – Nirvana,
1991. Essential.
2005
Show Boat – Original
cast, 1932. Deserved pick.
Time Out – Dave Brubeck
Quartet, 1959. Essential.
Live at the Regal – B.B.
King, 1965. Essential.
Are You Experienced? –
The Jimi Hendrix Experience, 1967. Essential.
Will the Circle Be Unbroken
– The Nitty Gritty Dirt Band, 1972. Understandable choice.
Songs in the Key of Life
– Stevie Wonder, 1972. Essential.
2006
The Button-Down Mind of
Bob Newhart – Bob Newhart, 1960. Essential.
We Shall Overcome – Pete
Seeger, 1963. Essential.
The Velvet Underground
and Nico – The Velvet Underground and Nico, 1967. Essential.
Burnin’ – The Wailers,
1973. Arguments could be made, but I agree.
Graceland – Paul Simon,
1986. Essential.
2007
My Fair Lady – Original
Broadway cast, 1956. I prefer the London cast, but okay.
Freight Train
and Other North Carolina Folk Songs and Tunes – Elizabeth Cotton, 1959.
Essential.
You’ll Sing a Song and I’ll Sing a Song – Ella Jenkins, 1966. I get why this is on here, and I'll allow it, but blegch.
You’ll Sing a Song and I’ll Sing a Song – Ella Jenkins, 1966. I get why this is on here, and I'll allow it, but blegch.
Music from the Morning
of the World. Great album.
For the Roses –
Joni Mitchell, 1972. I understand why they picked this, over ‘Blue’ and ‘Court
and Spark’. Not my choice, but not irreconcilable.
Head Hunters – Herbie
Hancock, 1973. Essential.
Thriller – Michael
Jackson, 1982. Essential.
2008
West Side Story –
Original Broadway Cast, 1957. Essential.
2000 Years with Carl
Reiner and Mel Brooks – Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks, 1961. Great album,
deserving choice.
2009
The Complete Village
Vanguard Recordings – Bill Evans Trio, 1961. Essential.
I Started Out as a Child
– Bill Cosby, 1964. Arguments could be made.
Today! – Mississippi
John Hurt, 1966. Great album.
The Band – The Band,
1969. Essential.
Red-Headed Stranger –
Willie Nelson, 1975. Essential.
Horses – Patti Smith,
1975. Essential.
2010
Talking Union – The
Almanac Singers, 1941. I think ‘Songs for John Doe’ is better, but I totally
understand this choice.
The Music from Peter
Gunn – Henry Mancini, 1958. Essential. ‘Breakfast at Tiffany’s’
notwithstanding.
Trout Mask Replica –
Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band, 1969. Essential.
Aja – Steely Dan, 1977.
Essential.
3 Feet High and Rising –
De La Soul, 1989. I understand this. I’d prefer A Tribe Called Quest, but it’s
a very reasonable pick.
2011
A Charlie Brown
Christmas – Vince Guaraldi Trio, 1965. Good pick.
Forever Changes – Love,
1967. Essential.
Mothership Connection –
Parliament, 1975. Arguments could be made.
Purple Rain – Prince,
1984. Essential.
2012
South Pacific – Original
Cast Recording, 1949. Essential. One of the better Rodgers and Hammerstein
musicals.
Descargas: Cuban Jam
Sessions in Miniature – Cachao, 1957. Sure. I get this.
The Shape of Jazz to
Come – Ornette Coleman, 1959. Essential.
Cheap Thrills – Big
Brother and the Holding Company, 1968. Essential.
The Dark Side of the
Moon – Pink Floyd, 1973. Essential.
Ramones – Ramones, 1976.
Essential.
Saturday Night Fever
Soundtrack – The Bee Gees, et al., 1977. Lots of filler, but I get it.
2013
A Night of Birdland –
Art Blakey, 1954. ‘Moanin’’ is more famous, but this had the virtuosity to
merit inclusion.
Celia and Johnny – Celia
Cruz and Johnny Pacheco, 1974. Essential.
Heart Like a Wheel –
Linda Ronstadt, 1974. Essential.
Sweeney Todd: The Demon
Barber of Fleet Street – Original Broadway Cast, 1979. Essential.
The Joshua Tree – U2,
1987, Essential.
Disagree
Songs for Young Lovers –
Frank Sinatra, 1954. Not Sinatra’s best. Why not ‘In the Wee Small Hours’?
Ella Fitzgerald Sings
the Cole Porter Songbook – Ella Fitzgerald, 1956. I love Ella, but she mangles
these tunes, and slows what should be jazzy numbers way down. Why not ‘Ella and
Louis Again’?
The New York Taxi Driver
– Tony Schwartz, 1959. Nope.
Judy at Carnegie Hall –
Judy Garland, 1961. I get why it’s on there, but I’ve never been a fan.
Giant Steps – John
Coltrane, 1959. Magnificent, but not Coltrane’s best. They really should have
put in ‘A Love Supreme’.
Fear of a Black Planet –
Public Enemy, 1990. Not their best. How do you not include ‘It Takes a Nation
of Millions to Hold Us Back’?
Tubby the Tuba – Victor
Jory, 1946. This is so dumb. Like, I get why it’s in there, but jeez…
We’re Only In It for the
Money – Frank Zappa, 1968. Should have been ‘Freak Out!’. Although, admittedly,
this is more ‘listener-friendly’.
Don’t Crush that Dwarf,
Hand me the Pliers – Firesign Theater, 1970. I just don’t find this funny.
Daydream Nation – Sonic
Youth, 1988. I’ve tried to like this album many times…
Live in Japan – Sarah
Vaughan, 1973. Tried and tried…
The Who Sings My
Generation – The Who, 1966. The definition of ‘uninspired’. ‘The Who Sell Out’,
‘Live at Leeds’, ‘Tommy’, ‘Who’s Next’: any of these would have been a better
choice.
Soul Folk in Action –
The Staple Singers, 1968. I really only found this to be about average, as
conscience-laden soul goes. Perhaps I’m being overly harsh, but only one or two
tracks stuck out.
Blind Joe Death – John
Fahey, 1959. ‘The Transfiguration of Blind Joe Death’ is better.
Barton Hall Concert at
Cornell University – Grateful Dead, 1977. Nope. If you want a live album do
‘Live/Dead’ or ‘Europe 72’. It’s not bad, but it’s not their best, by a
long-shot.
Sounds of Silence –
Simon and Garfunkel, 1966. Pick, like, any other album. The title track is
great, but ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ or ‘Parsley Sage Rosemary and Thyme’
are way better. Even ‘Bookends’ is better.
The Wild Tchoupitoulas –
The Wild Tchoupitoulas, 1976. Tried to like.
The First Family –
Vaughn Meader, 1962. Important, just not that funny. Of all my ‘disagrees’ this
is the most tenable for inclusion.
Carnegie Hall Concert
with Buck Owens and His Buckaroos – Buck Owens, 1966. Not a fan of Owens.
Shaft – Isaac Hayes,
1971. I get it, but this album, on retrospect, is too much filler around a hit
single.
Only Visiting This
Planet – Larry Norman, 1972. Do we really want to enshrine the birth of
Christian rock?
Haven’t Heard
1.
The Cradle Will Rock: Original Broadway Cast
2.
Precious Lord: Thomas Dorsey et al.
3.
Oklahoma!: Original Broadway Cast
4.
Winds in Hi-Fi: Eastman Wind Ensemble
5.
Live at Yankee Stadium: Fania All-Stars
6.
Guys & Dolls: Original Broadway Cast
7.
Switched-On Bach: Wendy Carlos
8.
Tuskegee Institute Choir Sings Spirituals:
Tuskegee Institute Choir
9.
Peace Be Still: James Cleveland
10. The
Eighty-Six Years of Eubie Blake: Eubie Blake
11. A Festival of Lessons and Carols as Sung on Christmas Eve in King's
College Chapel, Cambridge: King’s College Choir
12. Gypsy:
Original Broadway Cast
13. Azucar
Pa’ Ti: Eddie Palmieri
14. The
Continental Harmony: Gregg Smith Singers
15. Old
Time Music at Clarence Ashley’s: Clarence Ashley
16. Hoodoo
Man Blues: Junior Wells
17. The
Audience with Betty Carter: Betty Carter
18. The
Texas Sharecropper and Songster: Mance Lipscombe